Should you be afraid of a repeat?

Today’s economic outlook vs the 1970s recession?

It is our expectation that by the end of 2022, you will hear less of these forecasts. The simple reason is that the bond market leads inflation, and it has been made clear based on available information we should be more concerned with a deflationary growth scare in 2022.

During the 1970s recession…

The 10-year Treasury yield went from roughly 3.85% in 1962 to 4.80% in May 1966, which was the first month the CPI first broke above the 1964 high.

This is a large percentage change that occurred before a new high inflation reading. When inflation stalled in early 1967, the 10-year Treasury yield started moving much higher in anticipation of a re-acceleration.

Below is a graph from that era with the 10-year Treasury yield depicted in light blue and the core Consumer Price Index (CPI) annual change depicted in dark blue.

Today's economic outlook vs the 1970s recession? inflation and yields 1963-1975

The U.S. economy entered a recession in December of 1969, but you wouldn’t know this by looking at CPI, which is a lagging indicator.

The recession would last most of 1970 and you can see bond yields falling throughout despite still high CPI readings.

Finally, the inflation readings would plunge, but the bond market again correctly sniffed out the coming surge in the labor force, commodity shortages, and large deficits.

Bond yields never made a lower low in this recession and were moving substantially higher well before CPI spiked in 1974.

As an aside, all five recessions since 1980 have resulted in a new low in the 10-year Treasury yield.

It never hurts to get a second opinion.

Is your portfolio ready for “tomorrow”?

Find out how you can get a complimentary portfolio review

You can also see that inflation is ticking up to make new highs in recent months whereas the bond market set a lower high in October.

This doesn’t mean yields can’t move higher in 2022, but a repeat of anything like the 1970s has a very low probability given the historical track record of the bond market in forecasting inflation.

Below is the current situation where we have core inflation pretty much double the fifteen-year average and the 10-year Treasury yield well below average.

Today's economic outlook vs the 1970s recession? inflation and yields 2005-2021

Three strikes and you’re out

We would also push back against the narrative that once supply chains resolve themselves that an economic boom is poised to ensue.

The market is anticipatory and lagged data is far less important than how policy makers respond to this data. This is known as the reaction function. There are three big reaction functions taking place currently that will shape how markets perform in 2022.

The first reaction function is that of government-to-virus headlines. As we continue to go down the Greek alphabet there continues to be no deviation in the virus reaction function.

The latest mutation once again showed many large global economies default to lockdowns and restrictions whenever there are increasing cases or the threat of them. Since the virus can be spread through animals its eradication is all but impossible.

Therefore, more variations in 2022 with ensuing lockdowns pushes the global growth curve downward.

The second reaction function is fiscal stimulus, both domestically and globally. The United States is facing a significant fiscal cliff with government spending dropping significantly.

Estimates are about 2.5% of domestic GDP will come off in 2022 versus 2021 just due to less fiscal spending. China is facing a severe slowdown amid a property bust. They recently enacted some modest easing measures to help mitigate the pain.

It remains a question whether they will provide enough to offset their own shortfall, but there is no indication China is ready to inflate the global economy as they did after the Global Financial Crisis with huge amounts of stimulus.

Lastly, and most importantly, we have the Fed’s reaction function.

The latest plot twist has Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) Chair Jerome Powell pivoting to a hawkish rhetoric when speaking in front of the Senate Banking Committee. This helped set markets into a bit of a sell-off with the speculative equities coming under heavy selling pressure.

These are the types of investments that tend go down 50-80% when easy money dries up. This pivot is likely driven by politics, as blame for inflation must fall somewhere, and it is standard for elected officials to put such blame anywhere but upon themselves.

Don’t fall behind!

Stay informed on what’s happening today that might affect your tomorrow.

Delivered weekly, straight to your inbox.

* indicates required

What to expect in 2022

We expect Chair Powell to talk tough on inflation and sound extra hawkish whenever speaking in front of Congress. This should keep yield curves flat.

They may flatten more should economic data decelerate. The question is will they follow through with tough talk throughout the taper at each opportunity or will they talk tough in front of Congress, but back off during FOMC meetings and other prepared remarks.

By pivoting hawkish, the Fed created a window to be “less hawkish” at times, thereby helping bid up risk assets just enough to keep a back and forth.

Conversely, hammering home a desire to raise rates as fast as possible will be a big headwind to equities and corporate bonds as yield curves would resume their flattening cycle.

At this juncture, we have three reaction functions all pointing to lower growth and less policy support. This is supportive of long-end Treasury yields remaining low. We would expect the hawkish pivot by Chair Powell to persist at least into the second quarter of 2022.

He doesn’t want to flip-flop too much. However, we do think they will sprinkle in enough “less hawkish” remarks to keep markets from melting down like they did in the fourth quarter of 2018. However, this pivot does put the strike price much lower when it comes to adding support.

Therefore, should markets start to disfunction, the Fed may not be coming to the rescue until there is a lot of pain being felt.

The market is pricing at least two hikes in 2022. Often forgotten is the fact that much of the rest of the world has been in a hiking cycle for several months. This will be felt with a lag, especially amid decelerating global growth.

Below is a graph depicting the percentage of global economies whose leading index is higher versus three months ago. As you can see, the global economy is clearly decelerating. But more importantly, the three key reaction functions detailed above don’t do anything to change the current trajectory.

Today's economic outlook vs the 1970s recession? percentage of countries with increasing 3 month cli

We would lean to less interest rate hikes in 2022 than the market is pricing in and expect another Chair Powell pivot as the taper reaches its conclusion. We would not be surprised to see zero interest rate hikes in 2022.

The Fed has learned it is better to be pre-emptive than reactionary when it comes to policy support. Recessions have recently been shown to permanently alter the growth trajectory over the ensuing decade and labor force dynamics are severely impacted.

If they intend to do whatever it takes to support full employment, which we think they do, we don’t expect them to squeeze markets via interest rate hikes into a flattening yield curve to the same extent they have in the past.

The bond market probably sniffs this out ahead of time and long yields may bottom in the first quarter as a dovish pivot should see the yield curve steepen.

We would be wrong if global growth is accelerating again by mid-2022 and the yield curves remain sufficiently steep. This would give the Fed a window to raise rates and they would certainly take it as long as markets remained calm enough for them to do so.

We do think it will be the markets giving the all-clear signal and the Fed will be following their lead, not the other way around.

Source: BTC Capital Management, Bloomberg LP, Ibbotson Associates, FactSet, Refinitiv.
The information provided has been obtained from sources deemed reliable, but BTC Capital Management and its affiliates cannot guarantee accuracy. Past performance is not a guarantee of future returns. Performance over periods exceeding 12 months has been annualized.

The information within this document is for information purposes only and is not intended as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase or sale of any security. Statements in this report are based on the views of BTC Capital Management and on information available at the time this report was prepared. Rates are subject to change based on market and/or other conditions without notice. This commentary contains no investment recommendations and you should not interpret the statement in this report as investment, tax, legal, and/or financial planning advice. All investments involve risk, including the possible loss of principal. Investments are not FDIC insured and may lose value.

Content prepared by: Justin Carley, CFA, FLMI, Managing Director II

Investment and Insurance Products are:

author avatar
Daniel Davidson